Let's dive into the fascinating world of DC's latest cinematic venture, 'Supergirl,' and explore how it deviates from its comic book origins. Personally, I find it intriguing how filmmakers often take creative liberties with source material, and this movie is no exception.
A New Take on an Iconic Hero
'Supergirl' draws inspiration from the 2021 miniseries 'Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow,' but it's more than just an adaptation. The movie introduces a cynical and restless Kara Zor-El, a stark contrast to the optimistic superhero we know from the comics. This character shift is intentional, aiming to differentiate Kara from her cousin Clark Kent and provide her with a transformative arc.
What makes this particularly fascinating is the movie's exploration of Kara's internal struggle. She's portrayed as a wanderer, someone who hasn't fully embraced her role as a hero or found her place on Earth. It's an interesting psychological take on a character who, in the comics, is usually portrayed as confident and assured.
Streamlining the Story
The film condenses the eight-issue comic into a cohesive cinematic narrative. One notable omission is the entire third issue, which explores a discriminatory secret on a seemingly idyllic planet. The screenwriter, Ana Nogueira, explains this decision, stating that it didn't feel immediate to the main story. This streamlining is a common challenge when adapting episodic comic book stories into feature films.
Visual Deviations
'Supergirl' also takes a different visual approach compared to the lush, alien beauty of Bilquis Evely's art in the comics. The movie's aesthetic is more in line with 'Star Wars' or 'Guardians of the Galaxy,' with grimy starships and desert battlefields. It's a departure that might leave fans of the comic's unique art style feeling a bit disappointed.
A New Take on Krem
The villain, Krem, undergoes a significant makeover in the movie. He's transformed from a run-of-the-mill murderer into a formidable and feared space pirate. This change is inspired by 'Mad Max: Fury Road,' with the Brigands behaving like space Vikings and engaging in human trafficking. However, the movie doesn't fully explore the dark themes of trafficking, which could be seen as a missed opportunity.
A Different Ending
The movie's ending is a far cry from the comic's. In the film, Kara convinces Ruthye to let go of her desire for revenge, and then takes it upon herself to deliver justice by killing Krem. This is a stark contrast to the comic's ending, where Krem is sentenced to the Phantom Zone and later released, only to be non-lethally punished by Ruthye.
In my opinion, this change in the ending highlights the movie's focus on Kara's character development and her growth as a hero.
Conclusion
'Supergirl' is a bold adaptation, offering a fresh perspective on a beloved character. It's an interesting exploration of how a hero's journey can be reimagined for the big screen, and how visual and narrative choices can shape a character's impact. While it may not please everyone, it's a thought-provoking take on the iconic Woman of Tomorrow.
